Currently
55°
Clear

Advertisement





Opinion


Advertisement


CLASSIFIEDS


Free Ad

Place an ad
in print and online, 24/7 for free, select the Clean Sweep option. Unable to submit Real Estate, Services, and Business Investements at this time.

Get a Subscription


Map the Valley


Subscriber/
Reader Services

Subscribe Now
Contact Customer Service



Commentary: Religious squabbles generate much heat, little light

People act oddly during times of political uncertainty. Even so, I've been surprised lately to find myself agreeing with the perennially aggrieved William A. Donohue. For the uninitiated, Donohue serves as president, CEO and chief controversialist of "The Catholic League," a laymen's organization devoted to the dubious premise that bias against Roman Catholics is "more virulent and more pervasive than ever before in American history."

He's always on television, and he's almost always furious.

Actually, overt religious bigotry has become so rare as to be almost quaint in American life. That's not to say the Catholic League's brand of pre-Vatican II moral and theological conservatism is regnant everywhere -- particularly not among Catholics. Even so, Donohue's recently had a couple of real humdingers to wax apoplectic about.

First came Sally Quinn, the famous Georgetown hostess and founding editor of the Washington Post-Newsweek Web site "On Faith." Quinn's marriage to legendary Post editor Ben Bradlee -- the story of their adulterous courtship is narrated in his book "A Good Life" -- has made her a Washington social arbiter.

Attending Tim Russert's funeral Mass, Quinn decided to receive communion, then wrote about it. "Oddly," she reported, "I had a slightly nauseated sensation after I took it, knowing that in some way it represented the body and blood of Jesus Christ. Last Wednesday I was determined to take it for Tim, transubstantiation notwithstanding. I'm so glad I did."

Has "On Faith" no adult editors to inform Quinn that Catholic communion isn't for spiritual tourists? For once, Donohue got it right: "Just reading what Sally Quinn said is enough to give any Christian, especially Catholics, more than a 'slightly nauseating sensation.' ... Moreover, Quinn's statement not only reeks of narcissism, it shows a profound disrespect for Catholics and the beliefs they hold dear."

Elsewhere, a hubbub broke out at the University of Central Florida over a student who absconded from Mass with a consecrated communion wafer, either to exhibit it to his roommate or protest student funds supporting religious organizations on campus. The young man gave conflicting explanations to reporters. Church officials called his actions disruptive and disrespectful. He, in turn, complained that a woman attempted to wrestle the purloined Eucharist from his hand, and demanded a meeting with the bishop regarding church policy on physical force.

The word "hostage" appeared in local news accounts, along with overheated rhetoric about "hate crimes." Certainly "sacrilege" would apply. A week later, after allegedly receiving unconfirmed death threats, the student returned the consecrated wafer to church officials in a Ziploc bag. Everybody involved promised to pray for everybody else.

There this sorrowful little farce ought to have ended. Alas, the controversy caught the eye of P.Z. Myers, a University of Minnesota biology professor well known as the proprietor of "Pharyngula," a Web site mainly devoted to explaining and defending evolutionary theory against creationist nonsense. Alas, Myers also turns out to be a militant atheist. Infuriated by news accounts of the Florida debacle, he posted an essay titled "It's a Frackin' Cracker."

Denouncing "crazy Christian fanatics" filled with "Dark Age superstition and malice" threatening to kill a young man over a "cracker," Myers asked readers to "score me some consecrated communion wafers."

"I'll show you sacrilege, gladly, and with much fanfare," he vowed. "I won't be tempted to hold (the Eucharist) hostage ... but will instead treat it with profound disrespect and heinous cracker abuse, all photographed and presented here on the Web."

Look, as I find it necessary to remind somebody about once a month, threatening people you don't like is a felony. Pointing out that Myers is acting like an adolescent jerk, however, is not.

Arkansas Democrat-Gazette columnist Gene Lyons is a National Magazine Award winner and co-author of "The Hunting of the President."

(July 19, 2008)

POST A COMMENT

 

Hanfordsentinel.com encourages readers to engage in civil conversation with their neighbors. Comments that are submitted are not posted to the site immediately. They go into a queue to be moderated and may take several hours to be reviewed, particularly if they are posted after normal office hours.

We reserve the right to remove comments in total that violate our code of conduct. If you want to report a violation, please e-mail editor@HanfordSentinel.com

For more information please read our Terms of use, and Rules of the Road.

 


Please log in to post comments
*Member ID:
*Password:
  Forgot Your Password?
 
If you don't have an account you can create one for free by clicking the link below.
CREATE ACCOUNT
The following are comments from the readers. In no way do they represent the views of the Hanford Sentinel

Bernadette wrote on Jul 26, 2008 10:16 PM:

" It saddens me so to see in print in this article the horrific and sacrilegous comments made about the Holy Eucharist which Catholics uphold with the deepest respect as the Precious Body and Blood of Jesus Christ. As a Catholic who cherishes the gift of this Holy Sacrament, it is very difficult and painful to see such disrepect.

I understand that not everyone upholds the belief of the Catholic faith, but as a civilized people in a mostly Christian nation it should only be normal to expect respect in matters of religion.

I'm glad that there is a Mr. William Donohue and the Catholic League, who makes fellow Catholics aware of the many atrocities aimed at Catholics. I can only pray for those who so blatanly offend God. "




Advertisement


HOT TOPICS

> More Hot Topics


SENTINEL BLOGS

Going All-in by Richard de Give

The Fearful Football Forecast: Week 6

Maybe I was having self-esteem issues when this thing started, I don’t know. Or maybe it’s a good thing I pick a heavy diet of college games, since I know that game a little better than I do the NFL. Perhaps it’s just the pure joy of a baseball postseason with out the Yankees, or [...]

Signposts by Seth Nidever

Acedia

It’s an old word. Some translate it as exhaustion of the soul. World weariness. Soul sickness. It’s fallen in favor, out of favor, disappeared from use, and lately crept again into consciousness. You find the term popping up — in talk shows in the Bay Area, in conversations with friends, in exhortations from conservative thinker William [...]

Going All-in by Richard de Give

The Fearful Football Forecast: Week 5

Curse you, ESPN! Thanks to shifting around a couple of college football games to counter playoff baseball on TBS, I didn’t get a chance to make a pick on what could be one of the more intriguing WAC games of the season, La. Tech at Boise State. Worse, since morst folks here insist on watching Game [...]

Signposts by Seth Nidever

Maybe it’s not the economy, stupid

Fear grips Wall Street, and we quake. At the Sentinel, we’ve been living the crisis for days. Eating, breathing, and reading stories with headlines like “How bad the economy really is” and “Fallout on Wall Street worse than after 9/11.” Consternation hangs in the air like a cloud. What if our 401(k)’s evaporate? What if the Sentinel goes under? What [...]

Alien Asylum by Eiji Yamashita

Crazy items spotted at 99 cent store

If you haven’t been to the new 99-cent only store in town yet, do make the trip — but do it with extreme prejudice. You may find it extremely entertaining. I’m not usually a big fan of a dollar store of any kind (Being ‘frugalista’ frequenting a dollar store doesn’t necessarily mean saving money, let [...]

> More Blogs


MORE LOCAL NEWS

Lemoore:

Selma:

Kingsburg:



EMAIL UPDATES

Sign up today to get all your local headlines delivered to your home or work e-mail address, so you don't miss the latest in breaking and local news.
E-Mail:
Daily News Updates
Breaking News Alerts